WordPress SEO Audit: A Practical Checklist

This page is for WordPress site owners who want to check their own site before paying for help or buying tools. It walks through indexing, a crawl, on-page checks and how to rank the findings. For the automated version, see the tool linked below.

Short answer

A WordPress SEO audit is a health checkup of your site. Confirm your important pages are indexed, crawl the site for technical and on-page issues, then fix the highest-impact problems first.

Key points
  • Start with indexing: all important pages should be indexed, not every URL.
  • Crawl the site to find title, description, 404 and heading problems.
  • Keep internal search result pages out of the index.
  • Log findings in one spreadsheet with a priority column.
  • Repeat on a schedule: weekly, monthly and quarterly checks.
WordPress SEO audit order
1 Check indexing in Search Console 2 Crawl the site 3 Review titles, descriptions, headings 4 Log issues with a priority column 5 Fix top-impact items, then re-check
Work from indexing outward, then rank what you find.

What is a WordPress SEO audit?

It is a health checkup of your site that shows what works, what does not and what to improve. Yoast's audit guide frames it this way.

This page covers the manual process. If you want an automated scan, use the WordPress SEO audit tool. For costs of the plugins you might use afterwards, see WordPress SEO plugin pricing.

Step 1: Are your important pages indexed?

Check the Page indexing report in Search Console first. Google says most sites have at least a few unindexed pages, but all important pages should be indexed. The goal is not 100% coverage.

If Search Console is not connected yet, follow the guide to connect Search Console to WordPress. Also keep timing in mind: new content can take a few days to be indexed, so do not flag a page that is only a day old.

Signs of accidental blocking

A sudden drop in indexed pages can mean you are blocking access to existing pages. Check the plugin's indexing settings and your robots.txt.

Warning: Google says a robots.txt rule is not recommended for blocking a page and will prevent noindex from being seen. To keep a page out of results, use noindex and leave it crawlable.

See how to noindex a page in WordPress for the right method. If a whole new site is missing, read new WordPress site not on Google.

Step 2: Crawl the site

Run a crawler next. Yoast's checklist uses Screaming Frog, whose free version crawls 500 URLs.

From the crawl, list these issues:

Handling 404s and redirects

Google recommends fixing only the 404 errors that you link to yourself or list in a sitemap. Redirect URLs are not indexed, only the redirect target, so a redirected URL showing as unindexed is normal. The guide to 301 redirects for WordPress SEO covers setup.

Also check your sitemap loads. If it returns an error, see WordPress sitemap 404.

Step 3: Check on-page elements

Each page should have unique, targeted metadata. Each page should also have a single H1 tag that reflects the page's topic and primary keyword.

If many titles need changes, the bulk editing guide saves time.

Pages that should not be indexed

Internal site-search result pages should not be indexed, and Yoast tells you to watch out for this. Look for search URLs among your indexed pages.

Step 4: Prioritise and document

Put everything in one spreadsheet with a priority column. You do not have to fix everything; prioritise the issues you believe will have the greatest impact.

IssueExample findingSuggested priority
Important page not indexedService page excludedHigh
Accidental blockingIndexed pages drop suddenlyHigh
Linked 404sMenu link to deleted pageHigh
Duplicate titlesSame title on 12 postsMedium

The priority labels are a suggested way to rank issues, not a rule from the sources.

Worked example

A crawl of a 300-page site finds 14 pages with duplicate titles, 3 internal links to deleted pages and search result URLs in the index. You would log them like this:

Priority | URL/Group        | Issue                  | Fix
1        | 3 linked URLs    | 404                    | redirect or remove link
2        | /?s= URLs        | search pages indexed   | noindex
3        | 14 posts         | duplicate titles       | rewrite titles

The numbers here are illustrative. Fix rows 1 and 2 first, then re-check Search Console.

Step 5: Set a schedule

Yoast says to run a fresh crawl every quarter, and notes that full crawls are time-intensive. Plan lighter checks between crawls.

Common mistakes

Browse more guides in the WordPress learning hub.

Questions people ask

What does a WordPress SEO audit include?

In this checklist it covers indexing, crawl findings such as titles, descriptions, 404s and canonicals, heading checks, and a prioritised list of fixes.

Do all pages need to be indexed?

No. Google says most sites have at least a few unindexed pages, but all important pages should be indexed.

What tool can I use to crawl my WordPress site?

Yoast's checklist uses Screaming Frog, whose free version crawls 500 URLs.

How often should I run a full crawl?

Yoast says to run a fresh crawl every quarter, and warns that full crawls are time-intensive.

Should I fix every 404 error?

Google recommends fixing only the 404s you link to yourself or list in a sitemap.